The First Darkness Is London
The First Darkness Is London
Read moreReviews & Press
This page gathers selected reviews, critical essays, interviews, conversations, and reader responses concerning the literary and scholarly work of Salah el Moncef. It brings together substantial critical engagements with his books alongside conversations and other forms of reception.
For editions and publication details, visit the Books page.
Featured Critical Reception
Selected essays and reviews tracing the critical reception of Salah el Moncef’s fiction, from The Offering to The Woman from Warsaw.
LOS ANGELES REVIEW OF BOOKS
Memory, Trauma, and the Diasporic Subject
“one is simply dazzled by the sheer virtuosity of the language, the structure, and the rhythm.”
— Stephen Watt, Los Angeles Review of Books
ANGELAKI
“A Stranding in Strange Places”: Fiction in the Era of the New Wounded
A six-page scholarly review essay placing The Offering in the conceptual field of “the new wounded,” in dialogue with Malabou, Lacan, Stiegler, Jameson, and Eagleton.
— Stefan Mattessich, Angelaki 20.4 (2015), 261–266
MICHIGAN QUARTERLY REVIEW
The Art of World-Building: Salah el Moncef’s The Woman from Warsaw
“The Woman from Warsaw is that rare historical novel that feels both carefully researched and fully lived.”
— Stephen Watt, Michigan Quarterly Review
SAN FRANCISCO BOOK REVIEW
The Woman from Warsaw
“For those of us who appreciate historical fiction that prioritizes moral vision over mere facts, this is a masterpiece of war fiction.”
— Jessica Fahey, San Francisco Book Review
The Woman from Warsaw
CHICAGO BOOK REVIEW
The Woman from Warsaw
“a book that will stand out in my mind for years to come”
— Jo Niederhoff, Chicago Book Review
BOOKTRIB
A Lyrical Portrait of War and Survival in WWII Libya
“an evocative tale of history, hope and the healing effects of family and friends”
— Peggy Kurkowski, BookTrib
WORLD LITERATURE TODAY
Press praise for The Woman from Warsaw
“Moncef’s remarkable book insists that for those committed to preventing the recurrence of history’s violence, memory may be our foremost obligation…. This is writing at its most demonstrative.”
— World Literature Today
CBS NEWS
Press praise for The Woman from Warsaw
“Tracing the intertwined destinies of two women across a world undone by empire, Moncef renders history with rare immediacy and emotional force.”
— CBS News
ARIZONA DAILY STAR
Press praise for The Woman from Warsaw
“A haunting novel that captures the beauty and terror of a world collapsing.”
— Arizona Daily Star
COLORADO SPRINGS GAZETTE
Press praise for The Woman from Warsaw
“In this work, Moncef reveals the full measure of his craft—writing at the height of his powers.”
— Colorado Springs Gazette
Distinguished Responses
DAN DISNEY
“The Woman from Warsaw resists slogans. Its quietly heroic courage is its largest gesture, a transnational story in which solidarity proves mobile and exemplary.”
MAXWELL KENNEL
“Moncef’s Mariam Khaldoon is a poetic witness in a novel that is a memorial where needle and thread are transformed into a literary architecture of remembrance. The Woman from Warsaw is a rare creation to be placed alongside books like Leopoldo Marechal’s Adán Buenosayres and Carlos Fuentes’s Terra Nostra.”
Other Works
The Offering
Distinguished Responses
KHALED MATTAWA
“A tough, uncompromisingly ambiguous novel. And the sheer beauty of it—loads and loads of breathtaking beauty. This is a magnificent opus by an author whose glorious time has come.”
WILLIS BARNSTONE
“But genius does not heed reason…. Read this ravishing book and learn how to survive in the face of trying pain and loss. The breadth and depth and poetic power of The Offering will enchant you.”
MARI RUTI
“El Moncef’s prose, in short, achieves the quality of poetry…. The Offering is filled with such mesmerizing sentences—sentences where the reader can lose herself in rapt contemplation of the sheer elegance of expression.”
From the Introduction to The Offering
THOMAS NAIL
“A kinotechnical masterpiece for the modern age and a diasporic drama of profound beauty. The best novel I have read in a while.”
Selected Critical Reception
KIRKUS REVIEWS
The Offering — Best Books of 2015
“An immersive, finely wrought mystery of tragedy, loss, and recovery.”
— Kirkus Reviews
MODERNA SPRÅK
Scholarly review of The Offering
“a tragic but beautiful story of loss, fractured identity, freedom, salvation, and the limits of imaginative truth”
— Wade A. Bell Jr., Moderna Språk 111.1 (2017), 206–208
BOOKTRIB
Literary Tale of Sadness, Sorrow and Grief Told by a Poet
“an intense account of sorrow, sadness and grief as only a poet could tell it.”
— Joanna Poncavage, BookTrib
Now and Then
FOREWORD CLARION REVIEWS
Now and Then: Two Stories and Two Essays
“Now and Then is a fascinating literary collection whose stories are lustrous and lush and whose essays are erudite and theoretical.”
— Amy O’Loughlin, Foreword Clarion Reviews
SAN FRANCISCO BOOK REVIEW
Now and Then
“the specificity of 1930s Benghazi, which is brought to life for all the readers’ senses”
— Jo Niederhoff, San Francisco Book Review
Benghazi
MICHIGAN QUARTERLY REVIEW
“An Enormous Enigmatic Signifier”: Salah el Moncef’s Benghazi
“Stunning evocations of place and time abound in Benghazi.”
— Stephen Watt, Michigan Quarterly Review
MARI RUTI
Postface to Benghazi
“This is poetry as prose, prose as poetry.”
The Postface also reads Benghazi as a living, luminous city and as an “enigmatic signifier” whose incompleteness creates the desire for more.
— Mari Ruti, Postface to Benghazi (2022)
KIRKUS REVIEWS
Benghazi
Kirkus praised the novella’s “elegant and evocative” prose, its compelling setting, and the father–daughter relationship, while criticizing its slow pace and structural layering.
— Kirkus Reviews, review posted December 30, 2022
Interviews, Conversations & Commentaries
MANHATTAN BOOK REVIEW
Interview with Salah el Moncef, Author of Now and Then
A wide-ranging conversation on Now and Then and Benghazi, moving through memory, fascism, democracy, xenophobia, research, and writing between cultures.
— Kristi Elizabeth, Manhattan Book Review · October 17, 2022
BOOKTRIB
From Tunisia to France, This Author’s Novel Charts a Path of Artistry Amid Hardship
“If you choose to seek refuge in the life of the imagination in creative, constructive ways, that unique space within your mind will become your best remedy against life’s trials.”
— BookTrib Q&A · November 21, 2022
Selected Features & Commentary
BOOKTRIB
20 Favorites From 2022 That You’ve Probably Never Heard Of
The Offering was selected for BookTrib’s annual favorites list, which singled out Tariq Abbassi’s unreliable narration and the novel’s twisty structure of mysteries within mysteries.
— Jim Alkon, BookTrib · November 28, 2022
BOOKTRIB’S BITES
Four Great Last-Minute Ideas for Holiday Gifts
BookTrib featured Benghazi in its holiday selection, emphasizing the novella’s confrontation with Italian fascism and patriarchy and its story of a young woman finding resistance and hope.
— BookTrib · December 19, 2022
Readers
Distinguished Readers & Endorsements
WESLEY CECIL
On The Offering
“A work of extraordinary beauty and insight. A moving consideration of the tragedies of one man and an evocation of the broader human condition. Read this work to be deeply moved, to feel empathy, and hence to be more human. The best new work I’ve read in years.”
CHRISTIAN HAINES
On The Offering
“The novel can be read equally as a meditation on the impossibility of memory in the face of trauma and as a consideration of life in the diaspora. I recommend it for anyone interested in literature that is simultaneously experimental and pleasurable, artistic and entertaining.”
BARBARA CASE
On The Offering
“The Offering is a suspenseful, complex, and challenging psychological mystery. But most importantly, it is a novel of enormous literary beauty…. Despite the book’s complexity and laser-sharp focus on the inner psychological landscape of the main character, the story kept me spellbound.”
DAVID RAMBO
On The Offering
“From the first passages in its fictional forward, The Offering will intrigue you with mystery, trauma, and prose that pleasingly switches between terse and elegant.”
GERARD GREENWAY
On The Offering
“A highly compelling novel. The Offering is remarkable in the sustained intensity of its poetic sensibility. One is haunted by its capacity to plumb the abyss of loneliness, anguish and horror; enchanted by its power to evoke the magic of love and ‘the mysterious alchemy of people and places.’ A must-read.”
PHILIP METRES
On The Offering
“Salah el Moncef’s postmodern-cum-magical realist fiction reads like Kafka by way of Baudrillard.”
JASON BARKER
On The Offering
“Beautiful and spellbinding in its capacity to shock and seduce at once. The Offering is a triumph of the art of storytelling in an age shaped by digital technology and global cultural exchange.”
REBECCA GOWERS
On The Offering
“An exciting conception of the novel. Rare, these days, to pull off such a trick.”
Extended Reader-Critical Responses
JOHN GLENDENING
Truth in Poetry: Observations on Salah el Moncef’s The Offering
“It could also be called a first-person retrospective novel, a psychological novel, a philosophical novel, or a mystery. Ultimately it is something powerfully unique that resists easy classification.”
“Readers who welcome challenges I believe will be captured by The Offering—by Tariq’s intelligence, his fight to surmount his sufferings, his linguistic magic, and his moments of grace in the midst of confusions that envelop readers too as they try to understand what has happened.”
— John Glendening · Goodreads · October 2, 2018
CRISTINA IONICA
On The Woman from Warsaw
“Salah el Moncef’s The Woman from Warsaw (2026) offers a complex, thought-provoking snapshot of WWII fascist destruction and trauma through the eyes of Mariam Khaldoon, a young girl living in a multicultural Benghazi shaken and almost destroyed by the Italian fascist occupation.”
“Stylistically, the novel offers a rich texture of description and characterization steeped in well-researched socio-historical and cultural detail and always action-based.”
— Cristina Ionica · extended reader-critical response
Selected Reader Responses
A small selection of reader responses to The Woman from Warsaw, chosen for their attention to the novel’s visual prose, historical immersion, emotional depth, and moral atmosphere.
ALETHA PAGETT
On The Woman from Warsaw
“Never have I read a book whose words paint such incredibly vivid pictures. This novel of wartime Benghazi portrays a young woman coming of age in a time of moral choices and historical upheaval.”
ELSA JOSEPH
On The Woman from Warsaw
“From the opening pages, I felt transported into another place and time. The descriptions are vivid enough to see, hear, and almost smell the Mediterranean setting during wartime. Beyond the historical backdrop, the emotional journeys of the characters are what truly stand out. Their resilience and humanity make the story unforgettable. It’s a beautifully written novel that rewards readers who appreciate emotional depth.”
LLOYD BATES
On The Woman from Warsaw
“Some historical novels tell you what happened, but this one makes you feel as though you’re living through it. The vivid descriptions of wartime Benghazi create an unforgettable atmosphere, while the emotional journeys of Mariam and Esther make the story deeply personal. Their courage, compassion, and resilience shine through every chapter. The writing is elegant without feeling overwhelming, balancing historical depth with genuine human emotion. It’s the kind of novel that lingers long after the final page because its themes of hope and humanity feel timeless.”
DAVID TOWNER
On The Woman from Warsaw
“What impressed me most was the quiet strength running throughout the story. Rather than relying on dramatic twists, it builds emotional impact through thoughtful character development and beautiful prose. The historical setting feels authentic and immersive, while the themes of compassion and survival remain universal. It’s a novel that respects its readers by allowing emotions to unfold naturally, making every page feel meaningful.”
ALEX DORNELLI
On The Woman from Warsaw
“This story stays with you because it focuses on ordinary people facing extraordinary circumstances. The characters are wonderfully developed, making their struggles and triumphs feel incredibly real. The historical backdrop adds weight without overshadowing the emotional core. The writing flows beautifully, painting vivid images while keeping the story engaging from beginning to end. Anyone who enjoys meaningful historical fiction will likely find this an unforgettable read.”
FRANK
On The Woman from Warsaw
“What stayed with me most was how real the emotions felt. The characters experience fear, hope, loss, and compassion in ways that never seem artificial. The wartime setting is powerful, but it’s the humanity within the story that truly stands out. The writing has a quiet beauty that perfectly complements the emotional weight of the novel. A rewarding read from beginning to end.”
Latest Post
Lars von Trier’s Dogville and the Eternal Quandary: Grace or Justice?
Yet I had planted thee a noble vine, wholly a right seed: how then art thou turned into the degenerate plant of a strange vine unto me? Jeremiah 2:21 Und...
Read more
From Amazon
A work of extraordinary beauty and insight. A moving consideration of the tragedies of one man and an evocation of the broader human condition. Read this work to be deeply...
Read more
From Goodreads
Memory, Trauma, Confabulation, and Narrative Identity Play: An Unsettling Puzzle Tariq Abbassi, a French experimental poet of Tunisian origin, has lost his children, his memories, as well as his ability...
Read more
From Amazon Review
The intellect is practical by definition and likes to appear in control: classifying and categorizing; distinguishing between truth and falsehood, reality and illusion; putting clear ideas and demonstrations first. However,...
Read more